If you’ve started looking into roofing, you’ve probably asked yourself: “What’s the best asphalt shingle?” It’s a simple question, but the answer isn’t one-size-fits-all. The right shingle for your neighbor’s house might not be the best choice for yours. Let me break it down the way I’d explain it to a homeowner here in Mentor.
Why People Stick With Asphalt Shingles
There are plenty of roofing materials out there, but asphalt shingles are still the most common for a reason. They’re affordable, they come in a wide range of colors, and they hold up well in Ohio weather. Snow, ice, and summer heat they can handle it when installed properly. Plus, if something goes wrong, repairs are easier and cheaper compared to metal or tile.
The Three Main Styles
You’ll run into three types of asphalt shingles:
- 3-Tab Shingles – These are the flat, basic ones. They’re lighter and cheaper, but they don’t last as long. Good if you’re on a budget or not planning to stay in the home for decades.
- Architectural Shingles – These have more layers and a textured look. They’re sturdier, handle wind better, and usually last 25–30 years. Most homeowners I talk to go with this option.
- Luxury Shingles – The top tier. They’re heavy, detailed, and built to mimic slate or wood. They look fantastic and last longer, but they come with a bigger price tag.
What Really Matters When Choosing
So, how do you decide which one’s “the best”? Start with your situation:
- Planning to stay in your house long-term? Go with architectural or luxury shingles.
- Thinking about selling in the next few years? 3-tab shingles might do the job.
- Want your house to stand out? Luxury shingles can really boost curb appeal.
- Dealing with tough winters and strong winds? Pick something rated for durability.
It’s not always about the name on the packaging it’s about what matches your needs.
Shingle Brands Worth Mentioning
A few names always come up in roofing conversations:
- GAF – Their Timberline line is very popular and reliable.
- Owens Corning – Strong warranties, solid performance, and good for Midwest weather.
- CertainTeed – Heavier shingles that can last a long time if you want premium quality.
Each one makes good products. The “best” choice usually comes down to your budget and style preference.
The Sweet Spot for Most Homeowners
From what I’ve seen, architectural shingles are the sweet spot for most people in Mentor. They balance cost, looks, and lifespan better than anything else. That’s why you see them on so many homes around here.
Wrapping It Up
So, what’s the best asphalt shingle? The real answer is: it depends on your home, your budget, and your plans. The “best” shingle is the one that checks those boxes for you.
If you’re unsure where to start, a roof inspection is the easiest next step. At Roof Rejuvenate NEO, we’ve helped plenty of homeowners figure out whether their roof still has life left in it or if it’s time to consider new shingles.
